伦理 第4章 egoism,altruism,and social contract |
Egoism,Altruism,and the Social Contract
Altruism
unselfishness
Psychological egoism
descriptive
what people are like
acts only in heir own self-interest
classification
Narrow psychological egoism
short-term self interest
Broad psychological egoism
long-term interest
problems
problems
Ethical egoism
nomtive
how people ought to behave
people should act only from selfish motives.
classification
Individual ethical egoism
Universal Ethical egoism
Problems with ethical egoism
Grounding in psychological egoism
Consistency or coherence
self-contradiction
Derivation from economic theory
Conformity to commonsense moral views
Social contract
Contracrarianism
forms the basis of the political state
used to determine what justice requires
forms the basis of morality itself
Thomas Hobbes
People are naturally egoists
Everyone wants only to promote their own welfare
People are basically equal
In strength
In wisdom
No one can get absolute and secure power over others
The state of nature
no morality(All is allowed)
The social contract theory
人们自愿放弃一些权力换其他人放弃一些权力
People agreed to be bound by laws for their own sakes
People agreed to recognize such a power
the Leviathan
The state
Criticisms
no "state of nature"
没有考虑that cannot be rationally held to contracts
People lived in small tribes and societies
People are not completely egoistical